לרפואת פייגא בת יטא רבקה

🎓 Quiz

הלכות שכירות פרק ב · 5 Questions
Question 1
Which of the following categories is EXCLUDED from the Torah's watchman laws?
Land is excluded from watchman law. Only movable, non-consecrated property belonging to an ordinary Jew falls under the Torah's three-tier watchman system. A field cannot be stolen or lost in the relevant sense.
Question 2
A person says to a colleague: 'Place it down before yourself.' What custodian relationship is created?
The phrase 'place it before yourself' (or simply 'place it down') creates no legal custodianship. The person is neither an unpaid nor a paid watchman and takes no oath. The owner can only seek a general ban against whoever took his property.
Question 3
Can an unpaid watchman stipulate at the outset that he will be exempt from taking an oath?
Stipulations regarding money and oaths in monetary matters are fully binding when both parties agree — even without witnesses or a formal act of acquisition (kinyan). An unpaid watchman can waive his oath obligation.
Question 4
Grapes ready to be harvested but still on the vine — how are they treated under watchman law?
Produce still attached to the ground — even grapes ready for harvest — is treated as land for purposes of watchman law. The status is determined by attachment, not by ripeness or intent to harvest.
Question 5
A watchman has a written contract of deposit and now claims he returned the item. What oath must he take?
Since a document proves the custody relationship existed, the watchman's claim of return requires a more solemn oath — equivalent to a Scriptural-level oath (with a sacred object). This parallels the oath he would take if claiming an unavoidable accident.

← Back to Chapter 2
100%